TGC is a fantasy story, set in a parallel universe. The whole premise is that science and religion face each other, while the main character, a girl named Lyra is travelling across dimensions. As with every movie based on a book, I recommend reading the book first (and if!). The writer, English teacher Phillip Pullman, tried his best to create something different than "Lord of the Rings" and yet, to be it's equal. For many fans, His Dark Materials trilogy is considered an epic and original story, equal to LOTR and the best fantasy since ages...
RUBBISH! The movie is so horrid, it deserves to focus on several points seperatelly...
The acting: LOTR had amazing performances from almost every actor. Even some Orcs have memorable lines! In TGC, only Daniel Craig is saved, followed by the great sir Ian McKellen, who only performs as a voice over for the armoured bear Jorek and Sam Elliot, who performs decently. Craig is amazing, you wouldn’t believe how much class and energy he resonates, and as Lord Azriel is great cast and underused. He is on screen for 5 minutes total, and he owns them. His mannerisms, small gestures, intonation, you’ll have to rent the DVD and only watch his scenes to understand.
McKellen, on of the links to the LOTR trilogy, is superb. When the main character, Lyra, meets the armoured bear, Jorek, behind a small town store, the bear responds by standing tall, nearly as a human and then the booming voice of the man who was Magneto and Gandalf Is heard: It’s like it’s coming from the depths of the earth, it made the theatre tremble and it was supposed to be like that, right? Along with Ray Winstone’s voice for “Beowulf”, it was the best voice acting this year.
Sam Elliot is greatly stereotypically cast as air cowboy Lee Skorsby. You just know he’s gonna play the part on auto pilot and he’d be believable and acceptable. Nothing more, nothing less.
The rest is crap… Ignoring the fact that actors like Derek Jacobi and Christopher fuckin’ Lee are having 5 dialogue lines spoken (!!!), there is a bunch of unknown actors doing their worst impersonations of actors impersonating other characters. There is even a Gimli wannabe!
The main lead, Dakota Blue Richards, a newcomer and “a revelation”, as some magazines called her, is so inexperienced and seems lost among the green screens and the menir called Nicole Kidman.
Ah, the Academy Award® Winner Nicole Kidman. Her casting as Miss Coulter seemed like one of the all-time best. She is exactly as described in the book, only blonde. Which is, the book said that her hair was black, but I still kept imagining her as Nicole Kidman. But she acts so bored and bland in the movie! She is worse than a wooden mannequin. She speaks with such a pretended surprise and fake elegance, it’s unbearable. Whenever she appeared on screen, I couldn’t decide if I want to close my eyes or shut my ears. She is the exact opposite of Daniel Craig.
Eva Green is rescued by the fact that she is hot and appears on screen no more than 5 minutes. She seems to suffer from Kidmanitis in this film, but I can’t tell for sure. Her most annoying scene can be seen in various trailers, where she has the “I-kill-a-bad-guy-like-he’s-nothing” look when she kills a bad guy.
Let’s just pretend the acting is OK. There is an even bigger problem with the pacing. Forget that the whole story seems like it’s taking place during a weekend. There are scenes that drag along like an Theo Aggelopoulos movie, so boring and empty… People are talking and I was sitting there, waiting for them to stop, to move to the next scene, but no… A guy, sitting next to me, fell asleep, I shit you not! He even snarled! Rarely I felt the urge to stand up and leave the theatre – not because the guy next to me made funny noises, bur because the movie sucked!
What about the script and the story? Well, let me tell you, I’ve read the book. There is this strange thing going on with it: It is a mix of brilliant originality, preposterous thievery (from other fantasy books) and literary mediocrity. But some reason, when you read it for the first time, it feels grand and epic. Looking back, I realise this is not the case. Compare it to LOTR or Stephen King’s
Another strange thing is that, even if I had read the books, a long time ago, I still couldn’t make out what the characters were talking about in the movie!!! They keep talking about Dust and parallel universes and about the “prophesies of the witches”. Aaaargh, enough with the stupid prophesies already! Even after “Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace”, adding kids and prophesies in the mix seems like the worse idea ever and people still utilize it! Usually the world is at stake, here we talk about worlds. What makes the whole thing even more cheesy, is the fact that I don’t remember anything about a “prophesy” in the book, which means the script writer put in the idea. Because, what’s more original than a kid fulfilling an ancient prophesy, saving the world and learning an important lesson on the way.
So, what’s good? A few things, unfortunately. Besides the 2,5 actors doing a good job, the production values are top notch. Every setting, building, vehicle and little gimmick in Lyra’s world is interesting, original and well created. The effects are good, but nowadays nothing special – you’ve seen a CGI animal, you’ve seen it all.
My advice? If you are a casual moviegoer, stay away from this movie. If you are a harcore geek with a thing for fantasy, watch it on an illegally downloaded dvd.

